Ice Cream

Casey’s ice cream is made with homemade ingredients that are made fresh on site. We pride ourselves in using only the finest PA Dairy Products which are purchased locally. What sets us apart from many is that we take the time to make many of our own ingredients including our chocolate syrup, brownies, cookie dough, cinnamon buns, fudge and many more fine ingredients to enhance the flavor of our homemade ice creams. We always have an assortment of 40 flavors for your enjoyment.

Allergy Alert: Contains dairy and soy. May contain peanuts and walnuts. Manufactured in a facility that uses peanuts and tree nuts.

Ice Cream Flavors

Click any flavor for description and photos!
  • Blueberry

    Blueberry flavored ice cream loaded with real blueberries.

  • No Sugar Added

    Blueberry

  • Butter Pecan

    Butter pecan ice cream loaded with fresh roasted pecan halves.

  • No Sugar Added

    Butter Pecan

  • Cheesecake

    Made with a generous amount of pure cream cheese and swirled with strawberry or raspberry puree.

  • Chocolate

    The classic for chocolate enthusiasts!
  • Chocolate Almond

    Chocolate ice cream loaded with whole roasted almonds.
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter

    Chocolate ice cream loaded with fresh creamy Jif® peanut butter.

  • Cinnamon Bun

    Caramel Ice cream with chunks of fresh baked cinnamon rolls and cinnamon topping.

  • Coconut

    Coconut ice cream with angel flake coconut and chocolate pieces.

  • Coffee and Cream

    Coffee ice cream swirled with sweet cream ice cream.

  • Conneaut Lake Crunch

    Vanilla ice cream loaded with fresh roasted cashews and caramel.

  • No Sugar Added

    Cookie Crunch

  • Cookie Dough

    Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with chunks with our own recipe cookie dough.

  • Cotton Candy

    Tastes just like Cotton Candy!

  • Dizzy Lizzy

    Yellow cake batter ice cream with rainbow sprinkles.

  • Elephant Tracks

    Malted vanilla ice cream with chunks of our homemade peanut butter fudge.

  • Fire and Ice

    Cool creamy ice cream with homemade habanera pepper puree.

  • Fluff-n-Stuff

    Peanut butter ice cream with marshmallow fluff and chunks of peanut butter cookies.

  • French Vanilla

    Vanilla ice cream made with egg custard.

  • Frog

    Chocolate ice cream loaded with fresh roasted pecan halves and caramel.

  • Gooo Bananas

    Banana ice cream made with real banana puree and chocolate pieces.

  • Hannah Banana

    Banana flavored ice cream.

  • Hawaiian Crunch

    Coconut ice cream loaded with white chocolate chips, macadamia nuts,  crushed pineapple, and chunks of white chocolate chip macadamia nut cookies.

  • Irish Twist

    Irish Crème ice cream with chocolate covered pretzels.

  • Lemon Meringue Pie

    Lemon ice cream with marshmallow cream and pie crust.

  • Maple Walnut

    Maple walnut flavored ice cream loaded with English walnuts.

  • Meadville Mud

    Chocolate ice cream loaded with our homemade chocolate fudge and fudge sauce.

  • Mint Chip

    Crème de Menthe ice cream with chocolate pieces.

  • Mocha Fudge Crunch

    Mocha ice cream mixed with roasted almonds and our homemade thick rich fudge sauce.

  • Monkey Bones

    Chocolate ice cream with roasted peanuts, peanut butter and banana.

  • Nerd Heaven

    Blue Moon Ice Cream with sour candy Nerds.

  • Oreo®

    Vanilla ice cream loaded with pieces of Oreos®.

  • Peach

  • Pistachio

    Pistachio ice cream loaded with whole roasted pistachios.

  • Praline Pecan

    Praline ice cream with fresh roasted pecan halves and a praline caramel sauce.

  • Pumpkin

    Tastes just like Pumpkin Pie.
  • Razz-Izzle-Bizzle

    White chocolate mousse ice cream swirled with raspberry puree and chocolate truffles.

  • Really, Really Raspberry

    Raspberry ice cream loaded with raspberry puree.

  • Rocky Road

    Chocolate ice cream with English walnuts and marshmallows.

  • Rum Raisin

    Rum flavored ice cream loaded with delicious raisins

  • Snickers

    Vanilla ice cream with Snicker® candy bar pieces.

  • Squirrel Treats

    Vanilla ice cream with an assortment of fresh roasted nuts.

  • No Sugar Added

    Squirrel Treats

  • Strawberry

  • Sweet Potato Casserole

    Sweet potato ice cream made with real sweet potatoes, roasted pecans, toasted coconut and marshmallow.

  • Tippy-Toes

    Malted chocolate ice cream with chocolate covered pretzels and swirls of caramel.

  • Toffee

    Toffee flavored ice cream with toffee pieces.

  • No Sugar Added

    Toffee

  • Tupelo Honey

    Vanilla ice cream made with the rare and unique Tupelo Honey found in Florida along the Apalachicola River Swamps.

  • No Sugar Added

    Turtle

  • Vanilla

    The American icon. 'Nuff said.
  • No Sugar Added

    Vanilla

  • Vanilla Peanut Butter

    Vanilla ice cream loaded with fresh creamy Jif® peanut butter.

  • White Chocolate Fudge Brownie

    White Chocolate ice cream with homemade fudge brownies and a fudge sauce

  • White House

    Creamy vanilla ice cream with maraschino cherry halves.

We rotate our no sugar added ice creams for our friends watching their sugar intake. We always carry 2 flavors in the ice cream case at one time. Our rotating no sugar added flavors include:

Milkshakes

* Seasonal Availability

Milkshakes can be made with any ice cream available.

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Oreo
  • Black Cherry
  • Blueberry
  • Dreamsicle
  • Peach
  • Coconut
  • Chocolate Coconut
  • Pina Colada
  • Cheesecake
  • Raspberry Cheesecake
  • Strawberry Cheesecake
  • Blueberry Cheesecake
  • Root Beer
  • Raspberry
  • White Chocolate
  • White Chocolate Raspberry
  • Chocolate Raspberry
  • Mint
  • Chocolate Mint
  • Banana
  • Banana Split
  • Chocolate Banana
  • Chocolate Strawberry
  • Amaretto
  • Chocolate Amaretto
  • Peanut Butter
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter
  • Berry-Berry-Berry
  • Cotton Candy
  • Cherry
  • Chocolate Cherry
  • White House
  • White Chocolate Fudge Brownie
  • Pumpkin*
  • Honey*