Year-Round Flavors

  • Strawberry

    Strawberry

    Strawberry ice cream with strawberry purée

  • Cookie Dough

    Cookie Dough

    Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with chunks with our own recipe cookie dough

  • Really Really Raspberry

    Really Really Raspberry

    Raspberry ice cream loaded with raspberry puree

  • Chocolate

    Chocolate

    The classic for chocolate enthusiasts

  • Meadville Mud

    Meadville Mud

    Chocolate ice cream loaded with our homemade chocolate fudge and fudge sauce

  • Vanilla

    Vanilla

    The American Classic

  • Squirrel Treats

    Squirrel Treats

    Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with mixed nuts

  • Butter Pecan

    Butter Pecan

    Butter pecan ice cream loaded with freshly roasted pecan halves

  • Chocolate Almond

    Chocolate Almond

    Chocolate ice cream with almonds

  • Coconut

    Coconut

    Coconut flavored ice cream with angel flake coconut and chocolate pieces

  • Cotton Candy

    Cotton Candy

    Sweet and nostalgic cotton candy ice cream

  • Nerd Heaven

    Nerd Heaven

    Blue moon ice cream with sour candy nerds

  • Elephant Tracks

    Elephant Tracks

    Malted vanilla ice cream with chunks of our homemade peanut butter fudge

  • Raspberry Cheesecake

    Raspberry Cheesecake

    Made with a generous amount of pure cream cheese and swirled with raspberry puree

  • Vanilla Peanut Butter

    Vanilla Peanut Butter

    Vanilla ice cream loaded with fresh creamy Jif® peanut butter

  • White House

    White House

    Vanilla ice cream with maraschino cherry halves…a true classic

  • Dizzy Lizzy

    Dizzy Lizzy

    Yellow cake batter ice cream with rainbow sprinkles

  • Frog

    Frog

    Chocolate ice cream loaded with fresh roasted pecan halves and caramel

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter

    Chocolate Peanut Butter

    Chocolate ice cream loaded with fresh creamy Jif® peanut butter

  • Mint Chip

    Mint Chip

    Crème de Menthe ice cream with chocolate pieces

  • Cinnamon Bun

    Cinnamon Bun

    Caramel Ice cream with chunks of fresh baked cinnamon rolls and cinnamon topping

  • Blueberry

    Blueberry

    Blueberry flavored ice cream loaded with real blueberries

  • Conneaut Lake Crunch

    Conneaut Lake Crunch

    Vanilla ice cream loaded with fresh roasted cashews and caramel

  • Fluff n Stuff

    Fluff n Stuff

    Peanut butter ice cream with marshmallow fluff and chunks of peanut butter cookies

  • Snickers

    Snickers

    Vanilla ice cream with Snicker® candy bar pieces

  • Maple Walnut

    Maple Walnut

    Maple walnut flavored ice cream loaded with English walnuts

  • Awful Waffle

    Awful Waffle

    Vanilla ice cream with our homemade chocolate covered waffled cones and caramel

  • French Vanilla

    French Vanilla

    Vanilla ice cream made with egg custard

  • Oreo

    Oreo

    Vanilla ice cream loaded with pieces of Oreos®

  • Toffee

    Toffee

    Toffee flavored ice cream with toffee pieces

  • White Chocolate Fudge Brownies

    White Chocolate Fudge Brownie

    White Chocolate ice cream with homemade fudge brownies and a fudge sauce

  • Pistachio

    Pistachio

    Pistachio ice cream loaded with whole roasted pistachios

  • Rocky Road

    Rocky Road

    Chocolate ice cream with English walnuts and marshmallows

  • Cookie Monster

    Blue ice cream with an assortment of cookies and chocolate chip cookie dough

  • Rum Raisin

    Rum-flavored ice cream loaded with delicious raisins

  • Coffee & Cream

    Coffee ice cream swirled with sweet cream ice cream

Rotating Flavors

*four rotating flavors are in the shop at a time, call the shop for the current selections*

  • My Name Ain't Mud

    Double Dutch chocolate ice cream loaded with brownies, fudge topping, caramel, and toasted coconut.

  • Hanna Banana

    Hanna Banana

    Banana flavored ice cream

  • Goooo Bananas

    Goooo Bananas

    Banana ice cream made with real banana puree and chocolate pieces

  • Hawaiian Crunch

    Hawaiian Crunch

    Coconut ice cream loaded with white chocolate chips, macadamia nuts,  crushed pineapple, and chunks of white chocolate chip macadamia nut cookies

  • Irish Twist

    Irish Twist

    Irish Crème ice cream with chocolate covered pretzels

  • Lemon Meringue Pie

    Lemon Meringue Pie

    Lemon ice cream with marshmallow cream and pie crust

  • Monkey Bones

    Monkey Bones

    Chocolate ice cream with roasted peanuts, peanut butter and banana

  • Pumpkin

    Pumpkin

    Tastes just like Pumpkin Pie

  • Razz-Izzle-Bizzle

    Razz-Izzle-Bizzle

    White chocolate mousse ice cream swirled with raspberry puree and chocolate truffles

  • Sweet Potato

    Sweet Potato

    Sweet potato ice cream made with real sweet potatoes, roasted pecans, toasted coconut and marshmallow

  • Tippy Toes

    Tippy Toes

    Malted chocolate ice cream with chocolate covered pretzels and swirls of caramel

  • Banana Nilla Nutella

    Banana Nilla Nutella

    Banana pudding ice cream with Nilla Wafers and Nutella

  • Ginger

    Ginger Bean

    Vanilla bean ice cream with candied ginger

  • Squidney Lew

    Squidney Lew

    Avocado Ice Cream with honey and pecans

  • Go Bacon

    Go Bacon

    Maple ice cream with candied bacon pieces

  • Lemon Pop

    Lemon Pop

    A light lemon ice cream with poppy seeds

  • Candy Cane

    Candy Cane

    Peppermint ice cream with crushed candy can

  • Grasshopper

    Grasshopper

    Crème de menthe ice cream with Andes Candies and fudge sauce

  • French Toast

    French Toast

    French toast ice cream with real pieces of french toast

  • Carrot Cake

    Carrot Cake

    Carrot cake flavored ice cream with caramel and salty pecans

  • Vanilla Berry Crunch

    Very Berry Crunch

    Vanilla ice cream with granola and mixed berries

  • S'mores

    S'mores

    Graham cracker ice cream with fudge sauce and toasted marshmallows

  • Salted Caramel

    Salted caramel ice cream with caramel swirl

  • Mac Attack

    Double Dutch chocolate ice cream with fresh baked brownies and fudge sauce

  • Peanut Brittle

    French Vanilla ice cream packed with Casey’s Homemade Peanut Brittle.

  • Lucky Charms

    Lucky Charms Ice cream with marshmallow charms

  • Strawberry Pretzel Salad

    Strawberry Pretzel Salad

    Strawberry Jell-O Ice Cream, Swirled with a Cream Cheese Topping and Candied Pretzels

  • Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

    Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

    A Cake Batter Ice Cream, Pineapple, Maraschino Cherries, and all of the flavors of the iconic dessert.

  • Fire and Ice

    Cool and Creamy Ice Cream with Habenero Sugar Crystals